Of course it's unreasonable. Nothing about this place makes any sense. And why should it? That would be easy.

[The sarcasm in her voice is not for James. She's tired of being stuck in this town of perpetual winter, cut off from her friends and family, not even able to settle down and have a stable space of her own. She had her own bout of cabin fever once. She wasn't about to risk it again.]

I suppose it's possible there's someone who doesn't see things, but if there's anyone's that lucky, I haven't heard of them yet.